Dolby Atmos for music streaming is a waste of time

Dolby Atmos looks like the way forward for audio know-how. The thing-based encompass sound format has been round since 2012, and till not too long ago was used largely to craft exact, pristine sound mixes for films and tv. A couple of years later, Dolby Atmos for Music was launched, and was adopted by Amazon Music and Tidal for music streaming.

It wasn’t till 2021, although, when Apple launched its Spatial Audio characteristic for Apple Music and its AirPods Professional wi-fi earbuds, that Dolby Atmos actually took off within the music area. It was an thrilling growth, utilizing superior audio processing know-how to create a lifelike encompass sound impact utilizing only a pair of earbuds.

The know-how promised customers the sensation of being absolutely enveloped by the music they have been listening to, however after a number of years going backwards and forwards, I now simply maintain Dolby Atmos turned off in my Apple Music settings.

The encompass sound dilemma

An excellent thought, in concept

LG

In relation to films and TV, encompass sound has lengthy been the usual. And that simply is smart. An motion film will get that rather more thrilling when the viewer can hear bullets flying previous them, or helicopters overhead. Even in quieter dramas, a lush soundscape coming from throughout can imply the distinction between full immersion into the world of the story, and losing interest.

In music, although, encompass sound has a harder historical past. There have been a lot of codecs through the years that might ship encompass sound music, however they have been not often adopted by anybody aside from audiophiles. The massive motive for that’s, so as to pay attention, particular gear was required, together with a encompass speaker setup, which most individuals haven’t got. Moreover, it wasn’t actually attainable to take heed to that audio on the go, which is how most individuals take heed to music.

Associated

LG TVs now support Dolby Atmos in Apple Music — here’s how to listen

You’ll be able to take heed to tracks blended for Dolby Atmos from the Apple Music app immediately in your LG TV.

Enter Atmos

The fantastic thing about object-based audio

Encompass sound could have been a cumbersome know-how, however Dolby Atmos brought a new advantage to the table. Atmos is an object-based audio system, which implies that sounds are blended in a digital area, and might be mapped onto as few as two audio system, or dozens. In a movie show, audio system throughout, together with on the ceiling, enable Atmos to exactly reproduce the sound of that digital area. On a pair of headphones, the audio is mapped to provide the phantasm of that very same digital area, with sounds feeling like they’re coming from throughout you.

This new growth meant that it was instantly much more sensible to supply and distribute encompass sound audio for music, which Apple Music has taken benefit of in an enormous means. The transfer by Apple to undertake the Dolby Atmos format spurred report labels and music producers to start releasing extra Dolby Atmos music, together with going again and remastering previous albums for Atmos.

Associated

Does Dolby Atmos actually sound any better? Here’s what it can do

Dolby Atmos takes encompass sound to a different degree and provides you cinematic sound from the consolation of your property.

The issue with Atmos Music

It does not (normally) sound superb

TREBLAB Z7-Professional headphones as worn by a concrete head within the again yard. 

Atmos for Music does seem to be an excellent thought, and when it was first launched on Apple Music, I excitedly dove proper in. I even loved lots of the mixes I listened to. Taylor Swift’s albums sounded significantly good. These have been exceptions to the rule although. Again and again, whether or not new releases or previous remasters, I might come throughout mixes that sounded a lot flatter and tinnier than regular, and sometimes with out a lot of a encompass impact anyway.

Even the music that did sound good in Dolby Atmos, like Swift’s, would typically nonetheless sound higher after I turned off Atmos and switched to common previous stereo. The worst half was not figuring out whether or not a report would sound good or not, which had not been an issue for me previous to the introduction of Atmos. It appeared many producers merely did not know combine correctly for the format. My answer has been, merely, to maintain Atmos off in my iPhone’s music settings. This fashion, I at all times know I will be getting a correctly mastered stereo combine each time.

Associated

How to change the sound quality on Amazon Music and is there Dolby Atmos music?

Amazon Music has completely different high quality choices for its music – here is change issues up.

The place Dolby Atmos shines

There are exceptions to each rule

I could also be on the outs with Dolby Atmos for many music, however I do make just a few key excepts. To start with, some albums actually have been mastered properly for the format, to the purpose the place I want listening to the Atmos model. An instance of that is the Pixies’ traditional album Doolittle, which has a completely stellar Atmos remix. I’ll generally flip Atmos again on simply to take heed to that album.

The most important exception by far is with classical music and jazz. Whereas I’ve encountered just a few bum Atmos mixes in these genres, I’ve largely been astounded by what the format brings to them. There’s nothing like popping in your headphones and placing on Glenn Gould’s well-known recording of Bach’s Goldberg Variations and having it sound like he is really there within the room taking part in his grand piano. I’ve listened to jazz recordings that now, due to Atmos, sound similar to sitting in an precise jazz bar whereas the band performs.

Sticking with the tried and true

Newer does not at all times imply higher

Dolby Atmos often is the new factor in music, however that does not make it higher. As with something, it is determined by the way it’s used. Within the case of classical and jazz, Atmos is ready to breathe new life into already unimaginable recordings. With other forms of music, although, it is a way more blended bag. For each album that sounds nice in Atmos, there are a number of others that sound worse. That is doubtless as a result of producers are usually not used to the format, or deal with it as an afterthought, since most individuals will probably be listening to the normal stereo combine. Maybe, sooner or later, producers will get extra acquainted with Dolby Atmos, and it is going to be protected to maintain the characteristic turned on, however till that occurs, I am holding it off by default.

Associated

I listened Audible’s Dolby Atmos audiobooks to see if sound was better

The gathering is perhaps restricted, however what’s there may be value it.